ASC 815 does not provide specific guidance on the income statement presentation of gains and losses of derivatives that are not designated in a hedging relationship. Reporting entities may use derivatives for risk management purposes, but not designate them as hedges under the accounting literature. Some view these derivatives as “economic hedges” and believe they should follow similar income statement presentation as derivatives used in qualifying accounting hedges.
We believe a reporting entity may make a policy election regarding the income statement classification of derivatives that are economic hedges. A reporting entity may either report the fair value fluctuations associated with the derivative (1) in the same line as the hedged item or (2) in another reasonable income statement line item. For example, assume a reporting entity earns revenue in a currency other than its functional currency and executes a foreign currency derivative to hedge that exposure. Although it represents an economic hedge, the reporting entity chooses not to designate this derivative as a hedge under
ASC 815. The reporting entity may elect to either report the changes in fair value associated with the derivative in the revenue line or in the income statement with other derivatives not designated in hedging relationships. We believe either is acceptable as long as the policy decision is reasonable, applied consistently, and disclosed.
Splitting gains and losses into more than one income statement line item or “recycling” the gains and losses by recognizing them in different line items in different periods is generally not appropriate.
Question FSP 19-3
Reporting entities may issue warrants that are classified as liabilities and recognized at fair value through net income. The terms of these warrants may entitle the holder to dividend payments when dividends are paid to common stockholders.
How should the issuer classify the dividend-equivalent payments to the warrant holder in its income statement?
PwC response
The warrant holder’s right to dividend-equivalent distributions impacts the fair value of the warrant and should be included in determining the change in fair value of the warrant, which is recorded through the income statement. The payment in cash for the actual dividend reduces the recorded amount of the warrant on the balance sheet, representing a partial settlement of the warrant liability and therefore does not impact the income statement. Recognizing settlement payments in one income statement line with an offsetting change in fair value in another income statement line is generally not appropriate.
Question FSP 19-4A reporting entity has two derivatives. The first, an interest rate swap, economically hedges the reporting entity’s exposure to the variability in cash flows of a specific floating-rate asset. The second derivative, an interest rate cap, economically hedges the reporting entity’s exposure to the variability in cash flows on a specific floating-rate liability should interest rates rise above a certain level.
The reporting entity did not apply hedge accounting under
ASC 815. Because hedge accounting was not applied, these derivatives have been recorded at fair value on the balance sheet with changes in fair value recorded in current-period net income.
How should the gains and losses on the two derivatives be presented in the reporting entity’s income statement?
PwC response
We believe the gain/loss can be presented in the same income statement line item as the economically hedged item or in a separate line item, such as “other income/expense.” If the reporting entity took the former approach, the gains or losses on the two derivatives would be reported in different line items of the income statement. Gains or losses on the swap would be recognized in the “interest income” line item, while the gains or losses on the cap would be recognized in the “interest expense” line item. If the reporting entity took the latter approach, it would recognize the gains or losses on both derivatives in the “other income/expense” line of the income statement.
Whichever approach the reporting entity selects should be applied consistently. In addition, when derivatives are used as economic hedges of assets or liabilities, the reporting entity should disclose the purpose of the derivative activity and its accounting policy for the derivatives, including where the gains or losses are presented in the income statement and the amounts for each period.